Shopify blog
Authentic leadership is a management style based on self-awareness, ethics, honest communication, and consistent action. Authentic leaders know what they stand for and make decisions that reflect those values, even when the decision is difficult.
Values dictate who employees are willing to work for. The 2026 Edelman Trust Barometer reports that 42% of employees would rather switch departments than report to a manager whose values differ from their own.
This guide explains authentic leadership theory, its main characteristics, and how it compares with other management styles.
What is authentic leadership?
Authentic leadership is a management style that prioritizes ethics, emotional intelligence, and the good of the overall team.
An authentic leader steers their organization through strongly rooted values and a concern for employee well-being. This approach helps leaders earn trust, inspire loyalty, and make sound decisions that hold up over time.
Authentic leadership theory: the four components
Bill George, former CEO of Medtronic, brought the concept of authentic leadership into the business cultural zeitgeist in his 2003 book, Authentic Leadership. George’s authentic leadership theory emphasizes that a leader’s values, purpose, heart, relationships, and self-discipline enable them to make ethical, mission-driven decisions.
Business scholars have also examined authentic leadership. A 2005 paper by management professors Bruce J. Avolio and William L. Gardner, “Authentic Leadership Development: Getting To the Root of Positive Forms of Leadership,” examines authentic leadership theory in the context of other management styles, including charismatic leadership, servant leadership, and transformational leadership.
Avolio, Gardner, and management professor Fred O. Walumbwa later developed the Authentic Leadership Questionnaire. The assessment measures authentic leadership through four components:
- Self-awareness. Understands their strengths, weaknesses, and impact on others. Leaders seek honest feedback and recognize when their actions do not match their intentions. Awareness makes it easier to correct mistakes and change their approach.
- Relational transparency. Communicates openly about their decisions, concerns, and mistakes. They give employees room to question ideas or raise problems. Transparency doesn’t mean sharing everything. It means being honest about information that matters to the team.
- Internalized moral perspective. Uses their values to guide decisions, including choices that bring pressure or personal consequences. Their standards don’t change to please a superior, win approval, or secure a short-term advantage.
- Balanced processing. Considers relevant evidence and opposing views before deciding. They don’t dismiss information that challenges their position. For a major policy change, this could mean hearing from employees who will carry it out before approving it.
Leaders can complete the questionnaire themselves and ask employees to rate them, too. Comparing the answers shows whether employees see the leader the same way the leader sees themselves.
The four components reinforce one another. Self-awareness allows leaders to see their own biases. Balanced processing tests those biases against evidence. An internal moral perspective guides the final decision, and relational transparency gives employees an honest account of how and why it was made.
5 characteristics of authentic leaders
Authentic leaders lead with a moral compass and show steadfast commitment to their organization and its mission.
Self-awareness is key to this approach. They understand their values, motives, strengths, and limitations, then use that knowledge to guide how they lead.
According to George, these leaders share five characteristics:
1. Values
Authentic leaders live by a set of core values that stem from their personal ethics. They use these ethics and moral values to guide decisions both large and small.
For Uncle Studios Cofounder Allegra Shaw, fair pay is part of the cost of making clothes.
“Every garment is made by a person,” she says. “People need to be paid living wages.”
2. Purpose
A leader’s authentic behavior comes from a sense of purpose. They think in terms of their entire organization, putting core mission ahead of personal ambition. Combining this sense of purpose with core values enables them to become successful leaders.
3. Heart
Authentic leaders think beyond the financial bottom line when making decisions. They combine strategic thinking with empathy, and place a high value on their team’s personal needs.
They also demonstrate self-awareness, meaning they understand their own strengths and limitations, how others perceive them, and how their actions impact others.
4. Relationships
Authentic leaders place a premium on relationship building. Strong relationships help them build a successful team where colleagues feel valued and want to see each other succeed.
Leaders may build those relationships by sharing personal stories, asking for input, listening well, and offering advice.
5. Self-discipline
A disciplined leader can skillfully control their personal behavior and focus on the goals they’ve set. They set an example for other employees, who may feel inspired to commit themselves authentically to the organization.
Authentic leadership vs. other leadership styles
Entrepreneurs, executives, and managers use different leadership styles to guide their teams. With the authentic leadership style, leaders know their values and act on them consistently.
| Leadership style | Main priority | Shared with authentic leadership | Main difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Transactional leadership | Performance targets | Sets expectations | Uses rewards and penalties |
| Transformational leadership | Change and shared vision | Builds commitment | Leads major change |
| Servant leadership | Employee needs | Builds strong relationships | Puts employees first |
The impact of authentic leadership
Managers influence how employees feel about their jobs. Gallup found that only 20% of employees worldwide were engaged at their workplace in 2025, the lowest level since 2020. Low engagement cost the global economy an estimated $10 trillion in lost productivity.
“The most nerve-wracking thing is when I’m put into a situation where I’m not authentic and I’m trying to be someone else,” says Wallace Wong, cofounder of Spatula Foods. “That’s usually where mistakes happen.”
Authentic leadership offers five main benefits:
Trust
Authentic leaders say what they mean and follow through. PwC found that workers with the highest trust in their direct managers were 72% more motivated than those with the lowest trust.
Psychological safety
Authentic leaders admit mistakes and listen when employees disagree.
This makes it easier for employees to ask questions, report problems, and learn from failure. Only 56% of workers in PwC’s survey felt safe trying new approaches at work.
Engagement
Employees are more likely to care about their work when leaders explain its purpose and ask for their input. Gallup attributed most of the recent decline in global employee engagement to falling manager engagement.
Creativity
Employees share more ideas when managers listen. A study of 311 manufacturing employees reported that authentic leadership positively affected innovative work behavior, with employee engagement helping explain the result.
Performance
In a study of 214 employees, authentic leadership was positively related to performance. Employee commitment and creativity explained part of that relationship. When leaders act with transparency and stay true to their values, employees respond with greater engagement.
How to practice authentic leadership
Become a better leader by embracing the core principles of authentic leadership:
- Establish a set of values
- Lead with your heart
- Engage in dialogue with your team
- Practice what you preach
- Build self-awareness through feedback
1. Establish a set of values
Authentic leaders are guided by ethics and personal values. Use self-reflection to consider which core values will guide you as you lead and how you will model them for your employees.
For example, if work-life balance is one of your values, model it by setting healthy boundaries at work and respecting your team members’ boundaries.
2. Lead with your heart
Authentic leaders care about goals, but they also maintain positive workplaces as they pursue them.
As you guide your team toward new achievements, watch employees’ workloads and well-being. Give them enough time to manage stress, recover, and grow with the organization.
3. Engage in dialogue with your team
Authentic leaders don’t walk around the workplace barking directives. Instead, they engage in dialogue with their teams, soliciting strategic input and feedback. Speak to your colleagues with empathy and in human terms while avoiding business jargon.
Look for opportunities to expand the conversation beyond the day's tasks and loop everyone in on the big-picture goals you are pursuing.
4. Practice what you preach
Authentic leaders can demand a lot from their employees, but they never ask others to do things they wouldn’t do themselves.
If you ask employees to take shifts cleaning a communal kitchen, assign some of those shifts to yourself. Model authentic behavior and expect authentic behavior in return.
5. Build self-awareness through feedback
Ask employees and peers what you do well and what makes their jobs harder. Look for patterns in their feedback, then choose one behavior to change. If you need an outside view, find a mentor who will give you honest feedback.
Unbound Merino Cofounder and CEO Dan Demsky asked an employee during an early one-on-one, “What would it take for you to think I’m a great CEO? …I’m going to be honest with you, I don’t even know what I’m supposed to do.”
Training can help you improve your management skills. In Training magazine’s 2025 industry report, management and supervisory training received 13% of US corporate training budgets. It was also the area organizations most often planned to increase, at 30%.
For Shopify-specific training, Shopify Academy offers courses and learning paths on the platform.
Authentic leadership FAQ
What are the three pillars of authentic leadership?
The three pillars of authentic leadership are self-awareness, self-regulation, and ethics. Leaders understand their values and behavior, control their reactions, and use ethical standards to guide their decisions.
What are the pros and cons of authentic leadership?
Authentic leadership can improve trust, communication, and employee buy-in because people know what their leader stands for.
The downside is that openness can be uncomfortable, self-awareness takes work, and a leader’s personal values may not always match the needs of the company or team.
What are the four components of authentic leadership?
The four components of authentic leadership are:
- Self-awareness. Knowing your strengths and weaknesses.
- Relational transparency. Communicating honestly.
- Internalized moral perspective. Acting on your values.
- Balanced processing. Considering evidence and other views.
Are there any challenges associated with authentic leadership?
One challenge of authentic leadership is that it can take time to percolate through an organization, especially when employees are asked to change their own behavior to mirror their boss’s authentic leadership.
Is it possible for leaders to over-emphasize authenticity at the expense of other important leadership traits?
Yes, it is possible for an authentic leader to emphasize authenticity at the expense of short-term tangible results. If your organization faces a dire need to change course, such as a necessity to turbocharge revenue to avoid bankruptcy, you may need someone who leads authoritatively rather than authentically to accomplish that goal.
Is authenticity more important than experience in a leadership role?
Authenticity often stems from experience. This is because authentic leaders place their moral values front and center, and such values often come from life experience.
